More Idol stuff.
Mood:
quizzical
Now Playing: LMP -- Important
Topic: TV, music, movies, etc.
http://entertainment.msn.com/tv/article.aspx?news=158533
Report: Jammed Phones Skew 'Idol' Tallies
May 16, 9:55 AM EST
The Associated Press
Many would-be "American Idol" voters are disenfranchised by overburdened phone lines and by "power dialers" who hog the system, the magazine Broadcasting & Cable reported.
According to the magazine's issue being released Monday, "the only people choosing the next 'American Idol" are the ones lucky enough to get through -- or skilled enough to get around -- tremendously overtaxed phone lines."
Fox TV, which airs the talent contest, has failed to address the difficulties viewers must overcome to log votes, the magazine said.
The show is a ratings winner and valuable property for its producers and Fox, but Broadcasting & Cable said the network is alienating viewers who repeatedly get a busy signal when they try to call in their votes.
The voting system has been called into question in recent weeks as contestants who appeared to be front-runners were dumped in favor of others who many viewers have complained were lesser performers.
Last week, favorite La Toya London was voted off while Jasmine Trias survived a shaky performance.
Fox said both it and the show's producers have "gone to great lengths" to ensure the integrity of the voting process.
"While acknowledging that dedicated fans may be unhappy with the outcome, the system only reports the decision of the voting public," the network said in a statement.
The contest winner, who gets a record contract, will be decided in the series finale May 25-26. Trias, Fantasia Barrino and Diana DeGarmo are still in the running.
Questions about "Idol" voting are nothing new.
In last year's finale between Ruben Studdard and Clay Aiken, a total of 24 million votes were recorded, with Studdard declared the winner by a slim 134,000-vote margin.
But on the same night, Verizon, the nation's largest phone company, saw its daily volume increase by 116 million calls while SBC reported a call-volume increase of 115 million, according to Broadcasting & Cable.
That indicates a logjam in which millions of potential voters never got through, the magazine said.
Fox dismissed the allegation as speculative.
Viewers are allowed to vote repeatedly by phone during a two-hour window following the Tuesday show. Votes also can be cast by text messaging, which hasn't seen the same problems, the report said.
Jammed local phone lines, not the long-distance carrier network, creates the problem for callers, AT&T told the magazine.
Fox acknowledged there are times the phone network can't handle all calls due to the volume, but said it is using "the most sophisticated system available in the nation."
Ratings and call volume have risen over the show's three seasons.
Broadcasting & Cable said so-called power-dialers, who use fast Internet connections and computer autodialing software, also affect the outcome by the number of votes they are able to cast and by tying up lines so that others can't vote.
The magazine cited an August 2002 story by The Associated Press in which "American Idol" producers acknowledged power-dialers were casting thousands of votes.
In its statement Sunday, Fox said there are procedures in place to prevent individuals from "unfairly influencing the outcome of the voting," adding that producers can remove votes identified as power-dialing.
From the AI message board:
There will be a TWIST on Finale night... if you saw the latest AMerican Idol promo commercial it said there will be a "TWIST" on finale night...
wonder what the twist could be???
Here are some mb members speculating on the twist:
It could be a twist similar to the 'Survivor' twist at the end.
One winner is declared. And then they will let another winner be picked by America from all the other eleven contestants. Both will get instant contracts. (I like this one)
or maybe we can vote off the judges (Not a bad idea, either... except for Simon!)
The producers hand selected Idol will win; It was said from the beginning that the winner will definitely be a black female; and it is obvious who she is now; It was posted before the season even began; Everyone keep raging about the public voting when they really don't count anyway. The reason Jasmine is still there is because it's how the producers set it up. It had NOTHING to do with her getting so many votes for any reason at all. They want people to believe that and it is working just as they planned. Although Fantasia has been in the bottom votes a few times; Is'nt it ironic how she will all of a sudden win in the end; So go figure...it does'nt take much of a brain to do so. (Another conspiracy theory, this person is obviously adding fuel to the racism fire, stupid.)
the twist should be a duet with a famous singer (that would be VERY cool)
Maybe simon will do a little strip-tease.. (I'd pay to see that... how funny)
Yup, the last show will switch over to Fear Factor...the AI's face off! Whoever eats the highest volume in pig intestines wins! Woo Hoo!...oh wait...that's NBC...maybe they'll just let Alex decide which one he'd rather marry....but they only win if they correctly decide whether or not the groom is gay, LMAO.
maybe they will reveal that Paula is not a woman. simon is william hung's long lost father. randy and ryan are lovers (hehe)
How about they let the remaining girls fight it out? First Fantasia and Diana would go at it and the one left standing would face Jasmine since she is probably the weakest of the three. The method of fighting would be either boxing or mud wrestling. What y'all think? :-) (that would be great!)
maybe fantasia will get kicked off this week, and then on finale night they'll tell the truth and say that jennifer, latoya, and fantasia were the real top three and have an honest vote amongst the three. that would sure cause a big ol' hub-bub.
I heard they're bringing LaToya back for another chance..apparently there was some errors in reporting the votes (if only this were true...)
jasmine will gonna win the AI. do you remember when she was in the bottom 2 with camille and george she sing also, no one ever in the bottom 2 sings with the voted off finalists. it was only jasmine so far who were privileged to sing. therefore, jasmine will be the next AI, she is bankable because of her millions of solid fan base who is faithful to her all over the world. I for one is waiting for her single and album to come out. Mark my word, she will be the next AI 2004. no doubt and it is very true. (grrrrrrrrrreat, now if only she could teach her fan base proper use of the engrish...er, english language)
Yet another article:
Will your 'Idol' phone
vote really count?
By BILL HUTCHINSON
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER
Millions of fans desperate to vote for the next "American Idol" are being thwarted - and frustrated - by busy signals when they try to call the hit show.
And Broadcasting & Cable magazine says the next songbird to become "American Idol" is more likely to be picked by computer geeks called "phone phreakers" than by fans with a run-of-the-mill phone.
That's because the average fan of the Fox TV blockbuster is getting outfoxed by computer-assisted speed dialers, the magazine reported.
"It's a bandwidth problem. There's only so much volume they can run through that pipe at one time," said Tom Cobbs of Database Systems Corp., which designs complex telephone networks.
Hundreds of so-called phone phreakers have rigged their computers to flood the show's switchboard automatically with votes using high-speed Internet connections and auto-dialing software, leaving even phone speed-dialers in the dust.
"This is thousands upon thousands of moderately tech-savvy fans who really get emotionally compelled to do something about who they want to win," Kurt Knutson, a high-tech expert on TV's "Cyberguy," told the magazine.
"They're not only using the system to vote for whomever they want, they're using it to tie up the lines so that other people can't vote," Knutson said. The show's lines are open for two hours after broadcast.
But the show's producers insist the voting system is not problem-plagued.
"The producers and network have gone to great lengths to ensure the integrity of the voting process on American Idol," Fox officials said in a statement. "America votes, an independent company calculates the tally and the show reports those results."
The focus on fair play got foggier last week when fan favorite LaToya London was ousted from the show, while lesser-liked Jasmine Trias moved on to join Fantasia Barrino and Diana DeGarmo for a big showdown tomorrow night. The contest winner, who gets a record contract, will be decided in the series finale, May 25-26.
Viewers were still E-mailing the show's Web site yesterday to complain about getting shut out of the voting.
"I had my phone set on speed dial for Latoya and never once got thru. And I dialed and dialed!!!! Something is wrong with the voting system and it needs to be corrected or the country will [lose] complete interest in the show!!" one fan wrote.
posted by a cautiously optimistic Redskins fan
at 1:57 PM EDT